 鲜花( 1181)  鸡蛋( 48)
|
本帖最后由 小黄 于 2009-12-21 13:39 编辑 1 \ ^6 o* f5 C- _( F
你也别整呢些弯弯绕了。你就说吧:CIVIC和卡车撞,谁比谁更吸能?谁比谁更容易死?* e- C9 ~" P7 ^. d' i
降龙十八掌 发表于 2009-12-21 11:33  * L9 F+ l: R3 {" a
There is no data available. If you do have some, please share. But please don't make up scenarios and data yourself, that's 意淫. Use a published source, or statistically controlled experiment.# @7 u! u+ M; e1 [( `* M# |- O
; a9 q9 J g! c" ^From the existing data, there are 3 types of death:8 e. ^5 U% {$ y8 Q
1) MV: multi vehicle collision, like when a Civic hits another car/truck" w$ j9 o+ f- v9 V
2) SV: single vehicle, like hitting a tree, or roll over1 u0 J4 x) w; f a& V6 {
3) SV Roll: roll over, this a sub set of SV.
2 M# z; I; _0 N) S* n {6 o4 B3 q5 c$ ~0 p/ d5 D
For Honda Civic:) i. l O/ i0 R7 @5 O: m
MV 34$ b$ x n# o5 J$ \3 x' z4 l
SV 33
' D o' R% g9 Q: M+ tSV Roll 13. I7 k1 W8 _- g1 H" d
1 @ y0 E. y6 d( N
For Ford F150 (including super cab, crew cab): A4 L2 ~1 m7 Y
MV 28~34) G2 D5 d, N6 d8 z
SV 79~94
" p. E' Q2 Q- |5 M1 t; H; A) F' FSV Roll 48~82" [8 R2 z' ?- h0 l/ c4 S$ M+ u# y
9 p. v3 r+ f$ u" I B; {
For Chevy Silverado 1500:
$ X. f( C+ B" ^9 E2 K' h7 ?MV 40/ c" ~3 V0 I( B! f+ l( l! o
SV 85
! Y8 }3 {/ R' L% _5 W; ]+ _4 F) _SV Roll 61
* P2 I+ ^8 J. P! O: T; w" q
D, I5 R3 {5 K& \ F6 }As you can see, not only would the trucks roll over more easily, they don't perform better even in a vehicle on vehicle collision. So, yeah, Civic is definitely safer than F150 or Silverado. |
|